Alternatives to Etsy: Boost Your Sales and Grow Your Creative Business

Are you a creative entrepreneur or small business owner looking to elevate your products? If you’ve been relying solely on Etsy to sell your goods, it might be time to expand your reach and explore new opportunities in alternative online marketplaces. In this guide, we’ll introduce you to some amazing Etsy alternatives—including our very own platform—to help you grow your business and increase your sales potential.

Why Explore Alternatives to Etsy?

Before diving into the list of alternatives, it’s important to understand the reasons why expanding beyond Etsy could benefit your business:

Diverse Audiences: Each platform attracts a unique customer base. By exploring alternative marketplaces, you can tap into new audiences and expand your reach to potential buyers who may not be shopping on Etsy.

Reduced Competition: Spreading your presence across different platforms helps you reduce the intensity of competition, especially when other sellers offer similar products. This way, you can carve out a niche for your brand on each marketplace.

Increased Brand Visibility: Being active on multiple platforms increases your brand’s overall visibility. The more places your products are showcased, the more opportunities you have for potential customers to discover and recognize your brand.

Lower Fees: Some alternative marketplaces may offer more competitive fees to attract sellers. By diversifying your sales channels, you may find lower seller fees that can improve your profit margins.

Etsy Controversies: Recently, some Etsy sellers have reported issues with the platform withholding funds after sales, particularly in the UK. This has sparked backlash and led to organized groups like Etsy Reserve Strike. Diversifying beyond Etsy can help mitigate such risks to your business.

Outsourced Goods on Etsy: Etsy has also faced criticism for allowing outsourced items to flood the marketplace, diluting the authenticity of handmade goods. Some sellers have expressed frustration with competing against mass-produced products, which may not align with the platform’s original vision. Exploring alternatives allows you to focus on platforms that prioritize handmade or small-batch products.

Expanding your presence across multiple platforms could help your business thrive by reducing risks, increasing exposure, and improving profitability.

Let’s dive in on the pros and some of the cons of each below:

1. Amazon Handmade – A Marketplace Giant

Amazon Handmade offers artisans a platform to sell their unique, handcrafted items, backed by the power and reach of Amazon’s extensive marketplace. With its vast customer base, it’s an option worth considering for creators.

Pros:

Massive Customer Base: With access to Amazon’s millions of customers worldwide, you can reach a vast and diverse audience.

Prime Shipping: Take advantage of Amazon’s reliable shipping and fulfillment services to enhance the shopping experience for your customers, including Prime eligibility for fast delivery.

Trusted Brand Reputation: Selling on Amazon Handmade benefits from Amazon’s established reputation for customer satisfaction and trust, which can boost your credibility.

Fulfillment Options: You can choose between fulfilling orders yourself or using Amazon’s Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) services, which streamline logistics and make your products eligible for Prime.

Customer Reviews: Positive reviews can greatly enhance product visibility and sales. Quality products and great customer service often result in favorable feedback.

Sales Analytics: Amazon provides detailed sales data to help you make informed decisions on how to optimize your business.

Customer Service Support: Amazon offers customer support to both buyers and sellers, which can help resolve any issues and improve the overall experience.

Advertising Opportunities: You can run targeted advertising campaigns within Amazon’s ecosystem to increase your product’s visibility.

Prime Day & Seasonal Promotions: Amazon Handmade sellers can participate in major sales events like Prime Day, which can lead to a surge in sales during peak shopping periods.

Cons:

Fees & Commissions: Amazon Handmade charges several fees, including referral, subscription, and fulfillment fees. These can add up and impact your profitability.

Highly Competitive Market: With a large number of sellers, it can be challenging to stand out in Amazon Handmade’s crowded marketplace.

Limited Brand Control: Amazon’s strict guidelines on product presentation, labeling, and overall branding can limit your ability to create a unique brand identity.

Review System: Customer reviews play a significant role in your success. Negative reviews, even if unjustified, can harm your sales and reputation.

Strict Seller Policies: Amazon enforces stringent seller policies and performance metrics. Failure to meet these standards could lead to account suspension or closure, which could significantly disrupt your business.

Limited Customer Data Access: Amazon restricts access to customer data, making it difficult to build direct relationships with buyers or develop a customer database for future marketing.

High Return Rates: Amazon’s customer-first policies may lead to higher return rates, which can impact your bottom line and add administrative burdens.

Limited Control Over Fulfillment: If you choose to use Amazon’s FBA services, you relinquish some control over packaging and shipping, which can affect how your products are presented to customers.

Dependence on Amazon: Selling on Amazon Handmade means relying heavily on the platform. Any changes to fees, policies, or algorithms can significantly affect your business.

Global Competition: With manufacturers from all over the world competing on price, you might face pressure from cheaper products that could affect your pricing and profit margins.

Loss of Customer Ownership: Since Amazon controls the customer experience, you have limited influence over the post-purchase experience, making it harder to build a loyal customer base.

Conclusion:

Amazon Handmade is a great way to access a global audience and benefit from Amazon’s established reputation, but it comes with its own set of challenges. The competitive environment, fees, and lack of brand control may be drawbacks for some sellers. If you’re looking for mass exposure and reliable fulfillment services, it could be a good fit—but consider the trade-offs carefully.

While Amazon Handmade has it’s advantages, it’s important to weigh these pros against the platforms cons to determine if it aligns with your business goals and product offerings. Additionally, maintaining high-quality products and exceptional customer service is crucial to success on Amazon Handmade, as it can lead to positive reviews and repeat business.

2. eBay – An established Alternative

eBay has been a key player in the online marketplace world for years. While it’s traditionally known for auctions, it also has a robust system for fixed-price listings. Here’s why eBay could be a strong option for your business.

Pros:

Global Reach: eBay operates in multiple countries, providing the opportunity to sell internationally and reach a global audience.

Flexible Selling Formats: eBay offers both auction-style listings and fixed-price listings, giving you the flexibility to choose the best sales format for your products.

Seller Protection: eBay provides various seller protection policies, helping ensure that your transactions are safeguarded against potential issues.

User-Friendly Tools: eBay’s intuitive listing tools and templates make it easy for sellers to create product listings, manage inventory, and process orders efficiently.

Cross-Promotion: eBay often promotes your listings alongside related products, increasing the chance for cross-selling and upselling.

Secure Payment Processing: eBay integrates PayPal and its own managed payments system, offering secure payment options for both buyers and sellers.

Cons:

High Fees: eBay charges multiple fees, such as listing fees, final value fees, and additional fees for optional upgrades. These can significantly cut into your profits.

Complex Fee Structure: eBay’s fee structure can be difficult to navigate, varying based on factors like listing format, product category, and upgrades. Sellers need to carefully calculate fees to ensure profitability.

Highly Competitive Market: With millions of sellers, eBay is a very competitive marketplace. Standing out among so many listings, particularly in popular categories, can be challenging.

Feedback System: eBay’s feedback system can be helpful in building trust but can also be detrimental. Negative feedback, even if unjustified, can hurt your reputation and future sales.

Policy Changes: eBay frequently updates its policies, and staying on top of these changes can be time-consuming and challenging for sellers.

Payment Processing Delays: With eBay’s managed payment system, sellers may face delays in receiving funds, which could impact cash flow.

Returns and Refunds: eBay prioritizes buyer satisfaction, which can lead to more returns and refunds. This can be time-consuming and result in financial loss.

Communication Challenges: Interacting with buyers on eBay can sometimes lead to misunderstandings or disputes. Managing customer inquiries quickly is essential to avoid problems.

Seller Limits: New eBay sellers often face limitations on how many listings they can create, potentially hindering growth.

Shipping Costs: eBay buyers often expect competitive or free shipping, which can cut into profits, especially on larger or heavier items.

Listing Restrictions: eBay has restrictions on certain types of products, and accidental violations of these can result in penalties or account issues.

Seller Fees on Shipping Costs: eBay charges final value fees on both the sale price of the item and the shipping cost, which can significantly increase your expenses.

Performance Metrics: eBay enforces strict seller performance standards. Failing to meet these metrics can lead to account limitations or even suspension.

Dependency on eBay: Selling exclusively on eBay means you’re reliant on the platform for visibility and sales. Changes in eBay’s policies or algorithms can have a significant impact on your business.

Limited Customer Data Access: eBay controls customer data, restricting your ability to build a direct customer database for targeted marketing campaigns.

Counterfeit Issues: eBay has struggled with counterfeit and inauthentic items, which can damage trust in the platform and affect legitimate sellers.

Conclusion:

eBay offers a well-established, global marketplace with flexible selling options, but its high fees, competitive environment, and reliance on the platform can pose challenges. If you’re looking for an international reach and a simple selling setup, eBay may be a great option, but it’s important to be aware of the potential drawbacks like fees, policy changes, and competition.

It’s important for sellers to carefully weigh these cons against the potential benefits of selling on eBay and to develop strategies to mitigate the challenges they may encounter. Being informed about eBay’s policies and continuously improving your customer service and listing practices can help navigate these drawback successfully.

3. Shopify – Create Your Own Store

If you’re looking for complete control over your online presence, setting up your own store on a platform like Shopify can be a great choice.

Pros:

Full Customization: Shopify allows you to create a completely personalized online store that matches your brand’s identity.

Marketing Tools: Shopify offers a variety of marketing tools and integrations, helping you promote your products more effectively.

Ownership of Customer Data: Unlike marketplace platforms, Shopify gives you full ownership and control over your customer data, enabling you to build a customer database and run targeted marketing campaigns directly.

Multichannel Selling: Shopify supports selling across multiple channels, including social media, third-party marketplaces, and in-person sales through its point-of-sale (POS) system.

Custom Domain Name: With Shopify, you can use your own custom domain name (e.g., www.yourstore.com) to create a professional and branded online presence.

Lower Transaction Fees: Shopify’s transaction fees tend to be lower than those of platforms like Etsy, especially when using Shopify Payments, which can lead to higher profits.

No Listing Fees: Unlike platforms like Etsy, Shopify doesn’t charge listing fees, allowing you to add and manage an unlimited number of products without extra costs.

Extensive App Integrations: Shopify offers a robust app marketplace, enabling you to enhance your store’s functionality with tools for marketing, SEO, inventory management, analytics, and more.

Built-in Blogging: You can integrate a blog into your Shopify store, helping to boost SEO, engage your audience, and add valuable content.

24/7 Customer Support: Shopify offers round-the-clock support via email, chat, and phone, ensuring help is always available when you need it.

Cons:

Traffic Generation: One of the main challenges with Shopify is that, unlike marketplaces with built-in traffic, you are responsible for driving visitors to your store through your own marketing strategies. This requires time, effort, and often financial investment.

Costs Can Increase: While Shopify’s pricing is competitive, costs can rise as your business grows. Subscription fees may become more expensive, and additional apps or features can add to your overall expenses.

Learning Curve: For beginners, Shopify may take some time to master, especially if you’re new to e-commerce or website development. While Shopify offers user-friendly tools, setting up and customizing your store can require effort and time.

Limited Free Themes: Although Shopify offers some free themes, many premium themes come with an added cost. For highly customized or unique designs, you may need to invest in a premium theme or hire a designer.

Dependence on Apps: While Shopify’s app store provides valuable tools, relying heavily on apps can increase your monthly costs and the complexity of managing your store.

Design Limitations: Although Shopify’s themes are customizable, there are some design limitations that may be frustrating for advanced users who want full control over the store’s appearance and layout.

SEO Challenges: Shopify offers basic SEO tools, but some advanced features may require additional apps or custom coding. As SEO is highly competitive, you may need to invest in it to improve your store’s visibility.

Migration Difficulties: If you decide to move your store to another platform, migrating your data and design can be complex and time-consuming, which can be a barrier if you ever outgrow Shopify.

Product Restrictions: Shopify has limitations on the types of products you can sell, and some products—like digital downloads or services—may require additional apps or customization.

Inventory Management Limitations: Shopify’s inventory management features may not be as advanced as specialized inventory software, which could be a challenge for businesses with complex inventory needs.

Data Privacy Responsibility: While having full access to customer data gives you control, it also means you’re responsible for protecting that data and staying compliant with privacy regulations, which can be burdensome.

Conclusion:

Choosing to build your own online store with Shopify gives you maximum control, but it requires time and effort to drive traffic, manage costs, and handle technical aspects. If you’re comfortable with the platform or are willing to invest the time to learn, Shopify can be an excellent way to establish a professional, fully branded online store. For those seeking more customization, platforms like WordPress.org and WooCommerce might be worth exploring, offering full flexibility and control, though they come with their own set of challenges, particularly regarding updates and time commitment.

Mercari is a rapidly growing platform known for its user-friendly interface and wide range of product categories, making it a great option for sellers across various industries.

Pros:

User-Friendly App & Interface: Mercari’s mobile app simplifies listing and selling, appealing to tech-savvy buyers and sellers alike.

Wide Product Range: You can sell a variety of items, from handmade goods to electronics and everyday products, attracting a diverse audience.

Shipping Support: Mercari provides prepaid shipping labels, making the shipping process easier for sellers.

Lower Fees than Etsy: Mercari’s selling fees are typically lower than Etsy’s, which can result in higher profits for sellers or more competitive prices for customers.

Seller Protection: Mercari offers protections for sellers, including coverage for certain returns and fraudulent transactions, ensuring a safer selling experience.

Negotiation & Offers: Buyers can make offers on listings, giving sellers flexibility to negotiate and potentially secure sales on favorable terms.

Streamlined Payment Process: Mercari handles payment processing, which eliminates the need for sellers to manage multiple payment gateways and reduces transaction complexity.

Active & Large User Base: With a growing and engaged community, Mercari offers access to a broad audience of potential buyers.

Cons:

Limited Product Focus: While Mercari allows a wide range of products, it is more geared toward general consumer goods, making it less suitable for niche markets, handmade items, or vintage products that platforms like Etsy specialize in.

Smaller Niche Audience: If you’re selling specialized or handmade products, reaching your ideal customer base on Mercari may be more difficult, as it’s a more general marketplace.

Price Competition: Sellers offering similar items can drive prices down, which may impact your profit margins, especially for more common products.

Lower Price Ceiling: High-end or luxury products might not fetch premium prices on Mercari, as the platform caters to a broader, less affluent audience compared to specialized marketplaces.

Limited Branding Options: Mercari’s design is uniform, offering less opportunity for sellers to establish a unique brand identity compared to dedicated e-commerce platforms like Shopify.

Limited Customization: With fewer customization options for listings, Mercari doesn’t allow sellers as much flexibility to showcase their products in a personalized way.

Communication Restrictions: Mercari has strict guidelines for communication, which could make it challenging to engage in detailed conversations with potential buyers, particularly when discussing specific product details.

Limited SEO & Marketing Tools: Unlike other platforms with advanced SEO and marketing features, Mercari offers fewer tools for optimizing listings and promoting products, which may limit visibility.

Mercari offers a straightforward marketplace for a wide range of products, but may not be the best choice for sellers with niche, handmade, or luxury items due to its competitive pricing structure and limited customization options.

5. Poshmark – Marketplace for Fashion

If your business revolves around fashion, clothing, or accessories, Poshmark is the ideal platform to reach fashion-conscious shoppers and engage with a community of buyers and sellers.

Pros:

Fashion-Focused Audience: Poshmark is home to users who are passionate about fashion, making it perfect for sellers of clothing and accessories.

Social Shopping Experience: By integrating social features, Poshmark allows users to connect, follow one another, share listings, and participate in virtual “Posh Parties,” creating an engaging community atmosphere.

Simplified Shipping: Poshmark provides prepaid shipping labels, making the shipping process hassle-free for sellers.

Community Engagement: Poshmark fosters a sense of community, allowing buyers and sellers to interact, share listings, and engage in events like Posh Parties, which enhances the shopping experience.

Secure Payments: Poshmark handles payment processing securely, removing the burden of managing multiple payment gateways.

Negotiation and Offers: Buyers can make offers on items, enabling price negotiations and making it easier to reach a mutually acceptable price.

Seller Protection: Poshmark offers protection against certain types of returns and fraudulent transactions, ensuring sellers feel secure when making sales.

Exposure to Fashion Enthusiasts: With a dedicated fashion-forward audience, Poshmark connects sellers with buyers who are specifically seeking clothing and accessories.

Ratings and Reviews: Both buyers and sellers can leave ratings, helping to build trust within the Poshmark community.

Promotional Tools: Features like “Closet Clear Out” and price-drop notifications help sellers promote their listings and drive sales.

Easy to Start: If you’re familiar with fashion brands and styles, getting started on Poshmark is simple and straightforward.

User-Friendly App: Poshmark’s mobile app is designed for easy navigation, making it convenient for both sellers and buyers to engage with the platform.

Global Reach: Poshmark has expanded internationally, offering sellers a broader audience for their products.

Structured Messaging: Poshmark provides a structured messaging system and a clear return process, helping to manage customer interactions and resolve disputes efficiently.

Fashion-Specific Categories: Poshmark organizes listings into dedicated fashion categories, making it easier for buyers to find what they’re looking for.

Cons:

Limited Product Categories: Poshmark is primarily focused on fashion, so it may not be the best platform for selling items outside this niche, such as handmade or vintage goods.

Competitive Pricing: Due to the high volume of fashion items listed, the market can be competitive, often leading to lower profit margins.

Limited Branding Opportunities: Poshmark’s design is uniform, offering fewer opportunities for sellers to create a distinctive brand identity compared to platforms like Shopify or Etsy.

High Transaction Fees: Poshmark takes a flat 20% commission on sales, which is relatively high compared to other marketplaces.

Limited Customization: While you can set prices and descriptions, Poshmark offers limited customization options for listing layouts, store design, and branding.

Shipping Costs: Though Poshmark provides prepaid shipping labels, the cost of shipping is typically borne by the seller, which can reduce profits if not accounted for in the pricing strategy.

Lower Price Ceiling: High-end or luxury items may not fetch premium prices on Poshmark, making it less ideal for luxury brands or specialized marketplaces.

Buyer-Friendly Return Policy: Poshmark’s return policy favors buyers, allowing returns for various reasons, which could pose challenges for sellers.

Limited SEO & Marketing Tools: Poshmark offers fewer tools for optimizing listings and marketing compared to other e-commerce platforms, which could limit visibility and sales.

Mobile-Centric Platform: Since Poshmark is optimized for mobile users, sellers who prefer desktop-based listing and management may find it less convenient.

Restricted Payment Methods: Poshmark uses its own payment system, limiting options for both buyers and sellers when it comes to payment flexibility.

Platform Dependency: Sellers depend entirely on Poshmark for visibility and sales, meaning changes in policies or algorithms could significantly impact business performance.

Short Listing Duration: Listings are only active for 30 days, requiring relisting after the duration ends, which may take up additional time and effort.

Limited International Shipping: Although Poshmark has expanded globally, shipping options may be limited to certain countries, potentially restricting your international reach.

Poshmark offers a dynamic marketplace for fashion sellers, but its narrow product focus, fees, and competition might not make it suitable for every business.

6. Branabee – Your All-In-One Marketplace: Buy, Sell, & Auction

Branabee is a newly launched platform designed to offer users an affordable way to sell goods with extensive customization options. It handles marketing, sales tax, and many of the complexities of online selling, allowing you to focus on what you love.

Pros:

Free Listing: Sign up and start listing your items at no cost. Branabee only takes a percentage when a sale is made—simple, with no hidden fees or complicated pricing structures.

Lower Fees: At just 10%, Branabee’s fees are significantly lower than many competitors.

Expanding Product Categories: While Branabee primarily offers industrial parts and fittings, it is continually growing its product and seller categories to accommodate various niches.

Customizable Storefronts: Tailor your store’s design to reflect your unique brand and display your products in the most appealing way.

Inventory Management: Keep track of stock levels, manage product variations, and update listings for smooth operations.

Custom Listings: Create detailed listings with personalized descriptions, images, and pricing, to highlight your products’ best features.

Direct Customer Connections: Access customer data (including emails) to build stronger relationships with your audience through tailored marketing campaigns and communications.

Secure Transactions: Branabee prioritizes the security of transactions, providing peace of mind when you do business on the platform.

Marketing Assistance: Take advantage of Branabee’s marketing tools and promotional resources to increase your visibility and drive more sales.

Data Insights: Use detailed analytics and customer insights to make informed decisions regarding products, marketing, and inventory.

Customizable Policies: Set your own policies to create a personalized shopping experience that resonates with your customers.

Niche Market Advantage: Stand out in a more focused marketplace, unlike larger platforms such as Amazon or eBay, where the competition is fierce.

Multiple Income Methods: On Branabee, you can buy, sell, auction, or even rent products, offering a variety of income opportunities.

Seller Verification: Verified sellers gain greater credibility and marketplace trust, enhancing transparency and boosting sales.

Effortless Product Management: Easily add, edit, and manage your listings with an intuitive user interface.

Shipping Control: Customize shipping settings, including shipping locations, methods, and rates, for efficient order fulfillment.

Coupon Creation: Create and manage coupons and discounts to attract buyers and increase sales.

Vendor Support: Branabee offers support via live chat, email, or phone, ensuring assistance whenever you need it.

Scalable Growth: Whether you’re a small entrepreneur or a large business, Branabee accommodates all sizes, allowing you to grow at your own pace.

Reduced Competition: With fewer direct competitors than larger platforms like Etsy, Branabee gives you the opportunity to shine more easily.

USA-Only Focus: Operating exclusively in the United States, Branabee allows you to tap into a vast and affluent market, without the complexities of international shipping and regulations.

More Control: Branabee offers greater customization over your listings, store appearance, SEO, and branding than other marketplaces, giving you more power to shape your online presence.

Cons:

No Custom Domains: As of now, Branabee does not support custom domain names (e.g., www.yourstore.com), which may limit brand identity.

Limited Branding Control: While you can customize your store’s design, it may not be as flexible as owning a standalone e-commerce website.

Platform Changes: Branabee is constantly evolving, and sellers will need to adapt to new updates and changes that may affect store functionality.

Marketing Control: Sellers may have limited influence over the platform’s overall marketing and advertising efforts, meaning success could depend on Branabee’s ability to drive traffic.

Impact of Reviews: Negative reviews can influence your reputation and sales, making it crucial to maintain positive feedback.

Marketplace Policies: Sellers must adhere to Branabee’s rules and policies, which may impose restrictions on certain products or selling practices.

Limited Payment Options: The platform supports only a select number of payment gateways, which may not be suitable for all sellers.

Support Dependence: Sellers rely on Branabee’s customer support for issue resolution, but response times and quality may vary.

Limited SEO Control: Compared to managing your own site, Branabee offers limited control over SEO, which can affect your visibility on the platform.

Branabee provides a unique opportunity for sellers seeking a more customizable, lower-cost marketplace with plenty of room for growth. However, it may not be the right fit for those looking for total autonomy over their brand and online presence.

If you’re interested in creating a seller’s account, simply visit this link.

Conclusion

While Etsy has been a fantastic platform for creative entrepreneurs, it’s essential to explore alternatives to expand your online business. Whether you choose Amazon, eBay, Mercari, Poshmark, or Branabee, diversifying your online marketplace presence can help your small business thrive and grow.

Remember, each platform has its unique strengths and features, so take your time to research and find the one that best aligns with your brand and goals. Happy selling!